Content Warning: This article discusses sensitive topics related to gender-based violence (GBV).
Over the past decade, India has witnessed a surge in high-profile cases of gender-based violence that have captured national and international attention. These incidents have not only shed light on the pervasive issue of violence against women but have also sparked crucial debates about the effectiveness of the criminal justice system in addressing such crimes. This blog post examines the landscape of GBV in India, analyses the criminal justice response through the lens of several landmark cases, and compares India's experiences to those of Western countries.
Understanding Gender-Based Violence in India:
Gender-based violence encompasses a wide range of harmful acts directed at individuals based on their gender. In India, this issue is deeply rooted in historical, cultural, and socioeconomic factors. Common forms of GBV include:
Domestic violence
Sexual assault and rape
Acid attacks
Honour killings
Dowry-related violence
Child marriage
Human trafficking
According to the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB), India reported 377,057 cases of crimes against women in 2021. This figure marks a slight increase from the previous year, indicating a rise in reported incidents post-COVID-19 lockdowns. Despite this increase, experts argue that the numbers still significantly underrepresent the true extent of gender-based violence, as many cases remain unreported due to social stigma, fear of retaliation, and a lack of trust in the criminal justice system.
High-Profile Cases: Catalysts for Change
1. The 2012 Delhi Gang Rape Case (Nirbhaya Case):
Date: December 16, 2012
Background: The horrific gang rape and murder of a 23-year-old physiotherapy student in Delhi, known as the "Nirbhaya case," ignited unprecedented protests across India and drew global attention to the issue of sexual violence in the country.
Criminal Justice Response: This case led to the establishment of fast-track courts specifically for handling rape cases and significant amendments to the Indian Penal Code (IPC), including harsher punishments for sexual offences.
Current Status: All four adult convicts in the case were executed in March 2020, after exhausting all legal remedies, including mercy petitions. The swift execution was seen as a rare instance of justice being delivered relatively quickly in India.
2. The 2018 Kathua Rape and Murder Case:
Date: January 2018
Background: The abduction, rape, and murder of an 8-year-old girl in Kathua, Jammu and Kashmir, shocked the nation and highlighted the intersection of gender-based violence with communal and religious tensions.
Criminal Justice Response: The case drew attention to the need for more robust child protection laws and led to widespread debates about the politicisation of rape cases. The trial was moved out of Jammu and Kashmir due to concerns over a fair trial.
Current Status: In June 2019, a special court in Pathankot convicted six of the seven accused, sentencing three to life imprisonment and three others to five years in prison for evidence tampering. The case remains in the appellate courts, with the convicted individuals having appealed their sentences.
3. The 2019 Hyderabad Veterinarian Rape and Murder Case:
Date: November 27, 2019
Background: The brutal rape and murder of a 26-year-old veterinarian in Hyderabad sparked nationwide outrage, especially after the police killed the four accused in an encounter, raising questions about extrajudicial justice.
Criminal Justice Response: The encounter killing led to widespread debates about the ethics of such actions and the efficacy of the criminal justice system in providing timely justice to victims of gender-based violence.
Current Status: The case regarding the encounter is under investigation by the Supreme Court-appointed commission, which is examining the circumstances surrounding the police action. The findings of this investigation are awaited, and public opinion remains sharply divided on the matter.
4. The 2020 Hathras Rape and Murder Case:
Date: September 14, 2020
Background: The gang rape and subsequent death of a 19-year-old Dalit woman in Hathras, Uttar Pradesh, sparked widespread protests and criticism of the authorities, especially after the victim's body was hastily cremated by the police without the family’s consent.
Criminal Justice Response: The case brought to the forefront issues of caste-based violence and police negligence, leading to demands for greater accountability in the handling of such sensitive cases.
Current Status: The case is currently being tried in a special court in Hathras. The accused are facing trial for charges of rape, murder, and offenses under the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act. The trial is ongoing, with significant public and media attention on the proceedings.
5. The 2024 Kolkata Doctor Rape and Murder Case:
Date: August 2024
Background: The rape and murder of a young female doctor from R.G. Kar Medical College in Kolkata shocked the nation. The crime, occurring in a healthcare setting, underscored the vulnerability of women even in professional environments.
Criminal Justice Response: Following public outcry and concerns over the investigation by local authorities, the Calcutta High Court ordered the transfer of the case to the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) to ensure a more impartial and thorough investigation.
Current Status: The CBI is currently investigating the case, and the legal proceedings are in the early stages. The public is closely monitoring the case, with significant expectations for swift and just action.
Criminal Justice Response: Progress and Challenges
Progress:
Legal Reforms: The Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013, expanded the definition of rape, increased penalties, and introduced new offences such as acid attacks and stalking.
Specialised Units: Many states have established all-women police stations and special cells to handle crimes against women.
Fast-Track Courts: Dedicated courts have been set up to expedite trials in sexual assault cases.
Improved Forensic Capabilities: Investments in forensic science and DNA testing have enhanced evidence collection and analysis.
Challenges:
Underreporting: Social stigma and fear of retaliation continue to deter many survivors from reporting crimes.
Delayed Justice: Despite fast-track courts, many cases still face significant delays due to overburdened judicial systems.
Low Conviction Rates: The conviction rate for rape cases in India stood at 27.8% in 2020, indicating the need for stronger prosecution.
Victim-Blaming Attitudes: Persistent societal attitudes often blame survivors, making it difficult for them to seek justice.
Inadequate Support Services: Many survivors lack access to comprehensive support services, including counseling, legal aid, and rehabilitation.
India and the West: Comparative Analysis of Gender-Based Violence and Criminal Justice Approaches
While GBV is a global issue, comparing India's experience with that of Western countries offers valuable insights:
Legal Frameworks: Western countries often have comprehensive laws addressing various forms of GBV, such as domestic violence and sexual harassment. India has made significant strides in this area but continues to face challenges in implementation.
Reporting Mechanisms: Western countries typically offer more accessible and victim-friendly reporting systems, including anonymous hotlines and online platforms. India is working to improve its reporting mechanisms, but cultural barriers persist.
Support Services: Western nations generally have more extensive networks of support services for GBV survivors, including shelters and long-term rehabilitation programs. India is expanding its support infrastructure but faces resource constraints.
Public Awareness: Both India and Western countries have seen increased public awareness and activism around GBV issues, driven by social movements like #MeToo.
Intersectionality: Western approaches to GBV often emphasize intersectionality, considering factors such as race, class, and sexual orientation. India is increasingly recognising the need for intersectional approaches, particularly in addressing violence against marginalised communities.
The Way Forward: Strengthening the Criminal Justice Response
To effectively combat gender-based violence, India's criminal justice system must continue to evolve. Key areas for improvement include:
Comprehensive Training: Ongoing training on gender sensitisation and handling GBV cases for law enforcement, judiciary, and medical professionals.
Victim-Centric Approach: Adopting trauma-informed practices and prioritising survivor well-being throughout the justice process.
Community Engagement: Fostering partnerships between law enforcement and community organisations to improve reporting and support mechanisms.
Technology Integration: Leveraging technology for efficient case management, evidence collection, and data analysis.
Prevention Focus: Implementing evidence-based prevention programs targeting root causes of GBV, including gender inequality and harmful social norms.
Monitoring and Evaluation: Regularly assessing the effectiveness of interventions and reforms to ensure continuous improvement.
The past decade has seen India grapple with high-profile cases of gender-based violence that have both exposed the depths of the problem and catalysed significant reforms. While progress has been made in strengthening the criminal justice response, persistent challenges underscore the need for continued efforts to address GBV comprehensively.
By learning from both domestic experiences and international best practices, India can work towards a more effective, compassionate, and just response to gender-based violence. This requires not only legal and institutional reforms but also a broader societal shift towards gender equality and respect for women's rights.
As we move forward, it is crucial to maintain the momentum generated by these high-profile cases and translate public outrage into sustained action. Only through a collective commitment to change – involving government, civil society, and individual citizens – can India hope to create a safer and more equitable society for all its citizens, regardless of gender.
References
Ghosh, P., 2020. Delhi gang rape convicts executed: Nirbhaya case. [online] Available at: https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/delhi-gang-rape-convicts-executed-nirbhaya-case/article30968452.ece [Accessed 10 August 2024].
Sharma, R., 2019. Kathua rape case: Court convicts six men. [online] Available at: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-48789073 [Accessed 10 August 2024].
Kumar, S., 2020. Hyderabad rape-murder case: Encounter killing of accused sparks debate. [online] Available at: https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/hyderabad-rape-murder-case-encounter-killing-of-accused-sparks-debate-2135512 [Accessed 10 August 2024].
Singh, V., 2020. Hathras rape case: Police accused of mishandling the victim’s body. [online] Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/oct/01/hathras-rape-case-india-police-accused-of-mishandling-body [Accessed 10 August 2024].
Majumder, D., 2024. Kolkata doctor rape and murder case transferred to CBI. [online] Available at: https://www.livemint.com/news/india/kolkata-doctors-rape-and-murder-case-to-be-transferred-to-cbi-rg-kar-medical-college-calcutta-high-court-11723543470691.html [Accessed 10 August 2024].
National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB), 2021. Crime in India 2020. [pdf] Available at: https://ncrb.gov.in/sites/default/files/CII%202020%20Volume%201.pdf [Accessed 10 August 2024].
The Hindu, 2023. Nirbhaya case legal reforms. [online] Available at: https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/nirbhaya-case-legal-reforms/article32617931.ece [Accessed 10 August 2024].
BBC News, 2023. Kathua rape case updates. [online] Available at: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-56009772 [Accessed 10 August 2024].
NDTV, 2023. Hyderabad encounter killing case. [online] Available at: https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/hyderabad-encounter-killing-case-2023-2329090 [Accessed 10 August 2024].
The Guardian, 2023. Hathras case verdict and ongoing trial. [online] Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jul/10/hathras-rape-case-court-verdict [Accessed 10 August 2024].
© [2024] ClueChronicles. All rights reserved. No part of this article may be reproduced, distributed, or transmitted in any form or by any means, including photocopying, recording, or other electronic or mechanical methods, without the prior written permission of the publisher, except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical reviews and certain other noncommercial uses permitted by copyright law. For permission requests, please contact the author.
Comments